Hornbeam decline: uncovering a new threat to our ancient trees
Tree and Woodland Delivery Partner - The National Trust
In 2022, arborists from Urban Forestry (Bury St Edmunds) Ltd were undertaking specialist restoration work on veteran hornbeam pollards at the National Trust’s Hatfield Forest in Essex when they noticed something unusual. Several trees were showing signs of declining health, with thinning crowns, dying branches and areas of damaged bark.
Closer inspection revealed distinctive fungal fruiting bodies on affected branches, raising concerns that something more significant might be happening.
The discovery prompted investigations by Forest Research, which confirmed the presence of two fungi associated with a condition known as hornbeam decline. Although the disease had previously been reported in continental Europe, this was the first confirmed identification of the decline and one of the associated fungi, Cryphonectria carpinicola, in Britain.
An important discovery at Hatfield Forest
Hatfield Forest is one of Britain’s most remarkable historic landscapes. Its ancient woodland and wood pasture have been shaped by centuries of traditional management, including coppicing and pollarding.
Among its veteran trees are 196 hornbeam pollards, many of considerable age and ecological significance. Maintaining these trees through carefully considered restoration work is an important part of conserving the forest’s historic character and biodiversity.
It was during this work that arborists identified the unusual symptoms that triggered further investigation.
Two fungi were subsequently identified on declining hornbeams:
- Cryphonectria carpinicola – associated with branch cankers and distinctive orange pustules that emerge through the bark.
- Eutypella decipiens (previously Anthostoma decipiens)– producing red-orange, resin-like spore masses on stems and branches, sometimes accompanied by black bleeds. Eutypella decipiens was first reported in the UK in 1936.
Hornbeam decline has been reported in Europe (Italy, Austria, Switzerland, Germany and Georgia) as well as Iran, but the precise roles of either of these fungi in causing the condition in Britain remain uncertain.
Understanding hornbeam decline
Hornbeam decline is characterised by progressive thinning of the tree’s crown, often accompanied by branch dieback and canker formation.
Beneath the affected bark, fungal infection can be associated with extensive death of the living tissues, including the phloem and surrounding woody tissues.
However, the presence of these fungi does not necessarily mean that they are the sole cause of a tree’s declining health.
Tree decline is frequently a complex process involving several interacting factors. Heat seems to play a significant role in the decline, with Eutypella decipiens only fruiting above 26 degrees Celsius. But other stressors including drought, soil conditions, pollution, historic damage and frequent heavy pruning can all influence a tree’s physiological condition and potentially increase its susceptibility to the decline.
For ancient and veteran trees, which may have experienced centuries of environmental change and accumulated stresses, understanding these interactions is particularly important.
Bringing conservationists and arborists together
In June 2024, Forest Research and Urban Forestry (Bury St. Edmunds) Ltd led a workshop at Hatfield Forest, bringing together arborists and conservationists to share the findings and explore what hornbeam decline might mean for the management of these important veteran trees. The workshop combined an update on the emerging science with an opportunity to examine affected trees in the field. With experienced arborists on hand and a mobile elevating work platform (MEWP) available, participants were able to get a much closer look at the crowns of affected hornbeams, observing the extent of dieback and examining the symptoms that had first raised concerns two years earlier.
Forest Research shared findings from investigations involving 29 hornbeams at Hatfield Forest, including 15 showing symptoms of decline and 14 without visible symptoms. Laboratory investigations had identified the two associated fungi, while further research was exploring their growth characteristics and potential to cause disease.
The opportunity to inspect the trees from within the canopy was particularly valuable. Symptoms that can be difficult to distinguish from ground level become much clearer at height, allowing participants to better understand the distribution of dieback, the appearance of cankers and the distinctive fungal fruiting bodies, black bleeds and leaf curling in association with crown thinning.
The day highlighted the importance of collaboration between practising arborists, conservation managers and plant health researchers. It also demonstrated how the specialist skills and observations of those working directly with veteran trees can contribute to our understanding of emerging tree health threats.
What does this mean for our veteran hornbeams?
The discovery raises important questions for those responsible for managing ancient trees and historic landscapes. Are the fungi primarily responsible for causing hornbeam decline, or are they taking advantage of trees already weakened by other environmental pressures? How widespread is the condition, and what can be done to reduce its impact?
At present, there are no established treatments specifically for hornbeam decline, and research is continuing to better understand the relationship between the fungi and their hosts. For those managing veteran hornbeams, the emphasis remains on careful observation, monitoring and maintaining favourable growing conditions wherever possible.
It is also important to recognise that the presence of fungi should not justify intervention or removal, especially as hornbeam decline is thought to only kill 10% of trees affected. Veteran trees can remain ecologically valuable for many years despite significant crown decline or partial dieback. There is no need to panic and any management decisions should consider the tree’s condition, structural stability, habitat value and conservation significance first.
The importance of looking closely
Perhaps one of the most significant lessons from Hatfield Forest is the value of close observation and collaboration. What began with arborists noticing unusual symptoms during practical tree conservation work has developed into a wider research programme involving Forest Research, Urban Forestry (Bury St Edmunds) Ltd and the National Trust.
Further investigations, including aerial surveys and detailed inspections at other sites, are helping researchers understand how widespread the condition may be and what factors influence its development. Through the TreeAlert reporting system, Forest Research have isolated and identified fungal agents of hornbeam decline in at other locations in Essex and Greater London.
For now, arborists, woodland managers and conservationists are encouraged to remain vigilant for unusual crown dieback, branch cankers and the distinctive fungal fruiting bodies associated with hornbeam decline. Suspected cases can be reported to Forest Research through its TreeAlert reporting system. The work at Hatfield Forest demonstrates how practical conservation management and scientific research can work together to improve our understanding of tree health — and help safeguard some of our most valuable ancient trees for future generations.